The Literature-Based Basals in First-Grade Classrooms: Savior, Satan, or Same-Old, Same-Old?

Document Type


Publication Date



A longitudinal study of teachers in four districts across the state of Texas, we used a survey, interviews, and observations to examine changes in teacher practices related to the adoption of the new literature-based basal reader programs. Through surveys we collected the views of over 250 teachers statewide and focused on 14 teachers for a mon in-depth examination. We present our results in two stages: Year 1 was the baseline year before the adoption of the new programs, and Year 2 was the first year of the adoption. The survey and interview data suggested that in Year 1 almost all teachers were satisfied with the quality of instruction they provided students and had not made significant program modifications. However, we found major differences in teachers' practices; these differences were displayed on a continuum from those who did not use a basal but developed their own literature units, to those who used the basal including the teachers' manuals, to those who supplemented the basal with additional skills instruction, to the teacher who used only skills worksheets. In Year 2, we found some adjustments in practices. Some teachers did nor use the new basal at all, continuing in their literature only or skills only programs. Some teachers adopted the new basal with new methods of instruction; others adopted the new basal, but imported their old instructional methods; still others continued to use the old basals. We found that teachers' epistemological orientations were determining factors in how they responded to changes in teaching contest and how they adapted their practices to the new programs. Using Belenky et, al's (1988) ways of knowing framework, we found that most teachers worked within the same epistemological framework in Years 1 and 2. Additionally, we found that there was little staff development in any of the districts to support teachers' implementations of the new programs.




Hoffman, J.V., McCarthey, S.J., Elliott, B., Bayles, D., Price, D.P., Ferree, A., & Abbott, J.A. (1998). The literature-based basals in first grade classrooms: Savior, Satan, or ‘same-old, same-old?’ Reading Research Quarterly, 22(2), 168-197.



Tell us how this article helped you.